Secured vs Unsecured Loan for Bad Credit
Updated October 2026 · Rates from Bankrate, NCUA, Navy Federal, Experian, CFPB
A FICO score below 620 makes most mainstream unsecured loans expensive or unavailable. The practical path is almost always secured or cosigned: savings-secured or CD-secured personal loans, credit-union products, and credit-builder installments are cheaper than the subprime unsecured alternatives, and they rebuild credit.
Credit-score framework
The FICO scale is 300 to 850. Both FICO and VantageScore define rough tiers. Lenders set their own pricing grids inside these ranges; the lines below are what the broad market uses.
| Tier | FICO | What to expect on an unsecured personal loan |
|---|---|---|
| Poor | 300-579 | Many lenders decline; offers that come cluster near the 35.99% top of the market |
| Fair | 580-669 | Approval possible; rates well above the 11.90% G.19 average |
| Good | 670-739 | Broad approval; rates around the market average |
| Very good | 740-799 | Below-average rates at most lenders |
| Exceptional | 800-850 | Lowest advertised rates (from 5.96%) |
FICO tiers as published by myFICO. No public source publishes average personal-loan APRs by credit tier; the anchors are the 5.96% to 35.99% lender span (Bankrate, October 2026) and the Fed G.19 commercial-bank 24-month average of 11.90% (August 2026). Prequalify with a soft pull to see your own rate.
Your realistic options, best to worst
Predatory-lender warning
The CFPB notes that a common $15-per-$100 payday fee equals an APR of almost 400% on a two-week loan. Title loans (secured by your vehicle title) can carry APRs of up to 300% (CFPB) and permit repossession after one missed payment. Lease-to-own can double or triple the retail price of the item by contract end. All three product types are legal in most states but are explicit wealth-destroyers.
Alternatives before you ever walk into one:
- Employer payroll advance programs (often free or nominal fee)
- Nonprofit credit counselling via NFCC member agencies (debt management plans; free initial consultation)
- Dial 211 for local community-action agency referrals, utility-assistance, and emergency funds
- Credit-union "payday alternative loans" (PAL) capped at 28% APR under NCUA rules
- Religious or charitable organisations in your community that maintain hardship funds
Moving out of the bad-credit tier: six steps
Pay every bill on time
Payment history is 35% of a FICO score. Set up autopay for every minimum. One 30-day late can drop scores 60 to 100 points.
Cut utilisation below 30%
Utilisation is 30% of FICO. On a $5,000 limit, keep balances under $1,500 (ideally $500). Paydowns show up in the next statement cycle.
Dispute errors
Free reports at annualcreditreport.com from all three bureaus. Dispute inaccurate late payments, accounts you do not recognise, or wrong balances.
Preserve account age
Closing old accounts reduces available credit and average age, both score-negative. Keep old cards open; use them quarterly to prevent issuer closure.
Batch applications
Multiple hard pulls for the same loan type within 14 days count as one for FICO. Shop intentionally; do not leave a trail of random applications.
Add positive tradelines
A secured card or credit-builder loan adds fresh on-time history. This is especially powerful for thin files with few accounts.
Frequently asked
Can I get an unsecured loan with a 600 credit score?
Sometimes, but expect offers near the top of the market: lender-published personal-loan APRs run from 5.96% to 35.99% (Bankrate, October 2026), and the low end is reserved for excellent credit. Many mainstream lenders will decline. Credit unions are often more flexible with sub-620 scores than banks or online lenders and can underwrite with strong income and payment history compensating. Before applying for a subprime unsecured loan, compare a savings-secured personal loan (priced off your deposit rate: Navy Federal publishes share rate + 2.00% (up to 60 months)) or a credit-builder loan as cheaper alternatives.
What credit score is needed for a secured loan?
Secured loans are more accessible for thin or damaged credit files because the collateral absorbs most of the lender's risk. Savings-secured and CD-secured loans typically have no meaningful credit floor; approval is about confirming you own the pledged deposit. Home equity loans and HELOCs often approve down to a 620 to 640 FICO. Auto loans are available down to the 500 range through subprime lenders, though at high rates: Experian's Q2 2026 averages for deep-subprime borrowers were 16.11% new and 21.62% used.
What is a credit-builder loan?
A credit-builder loan is an installment loan designed for people with thin or damaged credit. The lender holds the loan proceeds in a locked savings account while you make monthly payments. Once the loan is paid off, you receive the funds. You have built 6 to 24 months of on-time installment payment history on your credit report. Many credit unions and Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) offer them in small amounts; check the APR in the lender's disclosure before you sign.
Which predatory loans should I avoid with bad credit?
Payday loans and title loans. The CFPB notes that a common payday fee of $15 per $100 equals an APR of almost 400% on a two-week loan. Title loans are secured by your vehicle and can carry APRs of up to 300% (CFPB), and they can result in repossession after one missed payment. Lease-to-own is a retail version of the same pattern at inflated total cost. The alternative path when cash is tight: employer payroll advance, nonprofit credit counselling (NFCC member), community action agency, or a call to 211 for local assistance referrals.
How do I move out of the bad-credit tier?
The six highest-leverage actions, based on the published FICO scoring-factor weights: (1) pay every bill on time, indefinitely, because payment history is 35% of the score; (2) bring card balances under 30% of limit (ideally under 10%), because utilisation is 30% of the score; (3) dispute any errors at annualcreditreport.com; (4) avoid closing old cards to preserve history length; (5) limit new hard inquiries outside of a 14-day rate-shopping window; (6) open a secured card or credit-builder loan to add positive tradelines.
Where to compare
Compare options from lenders that work with fair and poor credit
We do not quote specific lender APRs. These marketplaces do soft-pull prequalification (no credit-score impact) and return offers from lenders whose underwriting includes borrowers below 620.
These are plain links. We don't get paid if you apply.
Savings-secured personal loans
Step-by-step mechanics, worked example, credit-building angle.
Default risks
What happens if you miss payments on either loan type.
Cards for fair credit
Secured and unsecured cards for 580 to 669 FICO borrowers.